I just got back from a quick trip back to my hometown in Gladwin, Michigan. There were difficult family matters to discuss. It was one of those big ol’ hard discussions no one wants to have, but it went well and there is peace in my heart.

While I was there, I visited one of my mother’s oldest friends in a rehabilitation unit at our local hospital. (“Rehab” means she might be able to return home after her stay.)

It was our first meeting. Mom and Franny (not her real name) became friends when Mom started teaching middle school, after I’d already left home for college, over forty years ago. I’ve heard many wonderful stories about her over the years, and was delighted to finally see her in person.

Many, many interesting things happened during this little get-together, all of them great subjects for elder care and hospice articles.

But today I’m going to write about why being a saint is just too damn hard. And why we should…okay, could…just aim just a little lower. (Me trying not to tell you what to do.)

My mom’s favorite story about Franny involves Franny’s divorce after thirty years of marriage, her husband remarrying a younger woman, and her daughter’s wedding soon after.

Franny bought two new dresses for the wedding: A mother-of-the-bride dress for the wedding and another for the reception. She wore the first dress, and then switched to the second for the reception.

But when she got to the reception, New Wife No. 2 was wearing the same dress.

Franny went back to the dressing room and switched back to her other dress.

Mom has told this story many times, and she retold it several times while we visited Franny. Every telling ends the same way: “I tell her, “Franny, you are too good to be on this earth. You’re a saint! When you die, you’re going straight up to heaven!” (Always accompanied by a sweep of her arm and a dramatic point toward the sky.

But Franny didn’t nod her head or respond in any way. She’s obviously heard this from Mom many times, too.

I was sitting by her side, holding her hand. I said, gently, “You sound like a woman who picks her battles.” She nodded, but didn’t say anything. So that wasn’t all it was.

I said, “You chose to let your daughter have her perfect day on her wedding.”

And Franny brightened and nodded, and smiled.

I don’t know how to describe this lightening of the spirit. But when we speak, or hear, our truth, there is a subtle transformation that is beautiful. And this was Franny’s truth. Not the saintliness. Not the logical.

It’s about a tiny choice made with love.

Franny is not comfortable with being called a saint. She is not a wealthy person–a second dress for the wedding was not a small expense for her. It must have been so hard to be at her daughter’s wedding, watching her say vows that Franny and her own husband had taken so many years before. After a (supposedly) good marriage of thirty years, her husband chose to say those vows with another woman, who was sharing this important day with her. And she had to stand alone.

Of course she was angry! And indignant, confused. Of course she felt sadness, and regret, and who knows what else.

But she had the power of her choice.

She could choose to create a scene. She could choose to make a statement by not changing. After all, Franny was the mother of the bride. No one would blame her if she stuck to her guns and wore that dress with her head held high.

But she knew if she did, it would be her daughter who would suffer the most.

And she chose to change her dress. She made a choice, a tiny choice, a choice bathed in love.

When we call people ‘saints’, we think we’re talking about people who don’t feel those bad emotions. They are just naturally good. It’s easy for them. It’s so very very hard for us. Practically impossible, in fact, for us to rise above our human nature, our lizard brain. We just can’t be saints.

And so we let other people be saints. Because it’s just too hard, and we know we would fail.

What Franny did was different.

She thought it all through.

Her daughter’s happiness was in her hands for one short moment.

She could choose: Whose need would she serve?

And then she made a tiny, gracious choice.

We don’t have to be perfect. We don’t have to be good. We don’t have to even try to be a saint.

We can simply try to make a tiny, gracious choice, with love.

Wild Geese

You do not have to be good.
You do not have to walk on your knees
for a hundred miles through the desert repenting.
You only have to let the soft animal of your body
love what it loves.
Tell me about despair, yours, and I will tell you mine.
Meanwhile the world goes on.
Meanwhile the sun and the clear pebbles of the rain
are moving across the landscapes,
over the prairies and the deep trees,
the mountains and the rivers.
Meanwhile the wild geese, high in the clean blue air,
are heading home again.
Whoever you are, no matter how lonely,
the world offers itself to your imagination,
calls to you like the wild geese, harsh and exciting
over and over announcing your place
in the family of things.

from Dream Work by Mary Oliver
published by Atlantic Monthly Press
© Mary Oliver

You can hear Mary Oliver reading this, and two other poems here If you’re short of time, start at 1:05. But if you have a few moments, “Tom Dance’s Gift of a White Bark Pinecone” is pretty wonderful, too.

Author: Luann Udell

I find it just as important to write about my art as to make it. I am fascinated by stories. You can tell when people are speaking their truth--their eyes light up, their voices become strong, their entire body posture becomes powerful and upright. I love it when people get to this place in their work, their relationships, their art. As I work from this powerful place in MY heart, I share this process with others--so they have a strong place to stand, too. Because the world needs our beautiful art. All of it we can make, as fast as we can! Whether it's a bowl, a painting, a song, a garden, a story, if it makes our world a better place, we need to do everything in our power to get it out there.


  1. You’ve done it again, Luann – made me cry. Mary Oliver’s poem is one that I read in a book group gathering, but barely could get through.

    This article is oh so close to home, both as a divorced woman, and a mother of a disabled adult. I have heard words similar to “saint” used in reference to all I do, but it is so far from the truth. Working hard when you have to, and caring even when you don’t want to just happens. But there can be a few dark feelings that aren’t always shared because it doesn’t feel right to have them.

    Grace in accepting what you are given, learning from your choices, and letting love lead your actions, is the best one can do.


    1. Much to my surprised during a terribly sad time after the death of one of my sons, I had a moment of awareness that I had made a vow as a child to be a Good Girl so God would take care of me. I’ve since wondered if I would still be the same person if I hadn’t. I have no regrets about who I am because I ‘ve learned life is still about choices made from the heart or head. Love your story about Franny and the beautiful poem. Thank you so much.


  2. dear Luann, what a beautiful story this is about unconditional love a mother has for her children, thank you so much for sharing this with everyone:-) haydee


  3. Luann, thank you very much for this story. Going through my own divorce, and navigating the millions of choices everyday, weighing the demands of heart and mind and soul, individuality and family, love and anger and disappointment and pain… I have finally learned after much pain that it does come down to owning our choices and doing what is best is not always what makes us feel good right away, but what will not cause regret down the road.


    1. I’ve always thought that the choices after divorce are especially hard. It can seem there’s no “shared purpose” anymore. I’ve always admired the people who choose to act is if that purpose where still present.

      I’m not advocating people roll over to please everyone else first. Just acknowledging that sometimes we err on the side of compassion for others involved, AND ourselves.


  4. My daughter got married a year ago.I chose not to go to her wedding for many reasons but the main one was I didnt want to mar her day for her.My absence was so much less a threat than if I had gone.As a result of my staying away they had a beautiful day and it went all well.It was a choice I considered for months before I made it. A year later my daughter has been separated for 3 months already and her marriage is in a shambles.Reasons as yet unknown to me but I at least was able to give her the gift of a wonderful day without distraction. Those choices are hard and they mean you give of yourself.Others who do not make choices such as these dont understand ever. Franny I send you Love and hugs and to you too Luann. Thank you for sharing. Tanya


    1. Tanya, I’m so sorry your daughter’s happy day was only possible through your absence. I can only imagine the difficulties that made it your best possible choice. Kudos to you for choosing the more peaceful path.


  5. That’s just it…the people we call “saints” only make Godly choices every day, as a product of their access to a greater power—not their own virtue!! They still feel every lizardly emotion, but have the power to CHOOSE otherwise—often after an interior battle……Christians believe that Jesus gives them that sort of access to power. That’s about it. No superiority at all.


  6. Thanks, again, Luann, for revealing something so important. I find, that when I step on the “Saint Pedestal” for awhile, that I internally reject people’s compliment’s to me about it and start doing some really much-less-saintly things, to be sure I’m removed from that pedestal. Sometimes I think they compliment me, to avoid the effort of trying to do those things themselves. I’m sure some are really appreciative, but some are just trying to keep me going, doing what they don’t want to do themselves. When I go above and beyond, I don’t think of it as anything special…just seeing something that needs to be done, and someone has to do it, and, if you care about someone, you just do it. I feel everyone has their moments of being capable of it, but none of us can bat 100% and many simply choose to not even try. So, I can get pretty bitchy and resentful about it internally. As I told someone once, who was telling me they admired what I was doing and expressing that they could never do it, I responded, “I don’t believe that because I’m nothing special and anyone can do it, if they choose.”


    1. Wow, Patti, I feel like we are cut from the same cloth and I agree with everything you just said, especially with regard to compliments, and people’s supposed inability to do what we do.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: